Finxora Logo
Sign In
7 CMA Report Errors to Check Before a Bank Loan Application
Back to Blog

7 CMA Report Errors to Check Before a Bank Loan Application

FINXORA
6 min read
cma
bank loans
financial analysis
business funding
risk management

Check seven common CMA report errors before submitting a bank loan application, from inconsistent figures and weak projections to working capital assumptions.

Why a CMA report needs a careful review

A Credit Monitoring Arrangement (CMA) report presents a business's historical performance, provisional position and financial projections for a bank's credit assessment. It helps the lender examine working capital needs, liquidity, borrowing and repayment capacity. Errors can lead to queries, revised submissions or an adverse assessment, although a lending decision depends on much more than the report alone.

The objective is to make every material number explainable. A credit officer should be able to follow sales into receivables, profits into capital and borrowings into interest and repayment. Before submission, check these seven areas against the underlying books, supporting documents and the bank's requested format.

1. Historical figures do not reconcile with the records

A common problem is using different versions of the same financial year. Sales may come from an early trial balance while profit and capital come from signed accounts. A later audit adjustment then appears in one statement but disappears from another. The report can balance arithmetically and still misrepresent the approved financial statements.

Choose one final source for each historical year. Reconcile turnover, profit after tax, closing capital, fixed assets, inventory, debtors and borrowings. Where bank assessment requires regrouping, retain a schedule showing the original head, the adjustment and the assessed classification. Explain material differences between turnover in accounts and other supporting records instead of forcing the totals to match.

  • Identify audited, provisional and projected columns clearly.
  • Use the same reporting period and unit throughout.
  • Record every adjustment with its reason and source.

2. Projections lack an operational basis

A flat sales growth percentage is not a complete forecast. A manufacturer needs production capacity, utilisation, selling prices and raw material assumptions. A trader needs purchase availability, stock movement and customer demand. A service business needs an explanation of billable activity and collection terms. The assumptions should reflect how the borrower actually earns revenue.

For example, projecting sales from Rs 2 crore to Rs 3 crore requires an explanation of the additional Rs 1 crore. Identify whether it comes from volume, price changes, new customers or added capacity. Then include the related purchases, wages, overheads and working capital. Sales growth without corresponding resources often creates an implausibly strong projected margin.

Keep a short assumption note for each major driver. Distinguish confirmed orders from management targets, and explain why the projected performance differs from the historical trend.

3. Working capital is assessed using the wrong method

The turnover method and MPBF calculations use different assessment bases. They should not be treated as interchangeable labels. Under the Nayak Committee turnover approach for eligible MSME assessments, working capital requirement is commonly calculated at 25% of projected annual turnover, with borrower margin at 5% of turnover and bank finance up to 20%. Applicability and assessed amounts depend on the bank.

Under the Tandon Committee approach, MPBF Method I = 75% x (Total Current Assets - Other Current Liabilities). Method II = 75% x Total Current Assets - Other Current Liabilities. Other current liabilities here exclude bank borrowings. Method I requires a borrower contribution of 25% of the working capital gap; Method II requires 25% of total current assets.

Do not include the proposed cash credit borrowing in other current liabilities when applying these formulas. Confirm the lender's method, eligible asset treatment and margin requirements before presenting a requested limit.

4. Inventory and receivable holding levels are unsupported

A projected balance sheet needs working capital assumptions that fit the operating cycle. If annual sales rise while debtors fall sharply, the report should explain the expected improvement in collections. If inventory is projected below the level needed to maintain production, the resulting funding requirement may be understated.

Review inventory by category, customer credit periods, overdue receivables and supplier terms. Use consistent denominators for holding-period calculations: receivables commonly relate to credit sales, while stock categories may relate to relevant costs. State the basis used rather than comparing ratios calculated differently across years.

Separate normal operating balances from slow-moving stock, disputed receivables or amounts whose eligibility the bank needs to assess. A full accounting asset balance is not automatically the amount accepted for lending purposes.

5. Profit, cash flow and debt service contradict each other

Accounting profit does not equal cash available for repayments. Higher sales can absorb cash through inventory and debtors. Fixed asset purchases, drawings, taxes and loan instalments can reduce cash even when the operating statement shows a profit. Check the cash flow and fund flow alongside the balance sheet.

Match term loan repayments to the repayment schedule and closing loan balances. Calculate interest using a reasonable borrowing and timing assumption. If DSCR is presented, disclose the cash accrual and debt service components used, including how interest and principal are treated, and follow the lender's required definition.

A report showing increasing bank balances alongside an unexplained rise in cash credit needs investigation. Trace the movement through operating cash, capital spending and financing before changing an individual total.

6. Supporting evidence and presentation are incomplete

A technically sound calculation becomes difficult to assess when the supporting records cannot be located. Prepare an indexed set of documents requested by the lender, such as signed financial statements, provisional accounts, debt schedules, stock records and bank statements. Avoid attaching unrelated material merely to increase the size of the file.

Label the borrower, constitution, year ending, currency unit and document status on the report. Use consistent headings and readable tables. A change from rupees to lakhs between sections can create a large apparent discrepancy even if the underlying spreadsheet formulas are correct.

Check that the narrative describes the same business and funding purpose as the financial tables. Remove placeholder names, outdated loan amounts and statements carried forward from a previous application.

7. Risks and sensitivities receive no practical explanation

Projections should show how the borrower could respond if important assumptions change. Test a lower sales level, slower collections or a higher input cost. Identify which changes affect profit, cash availability and working capital need. Keep the assumptions connected across statements rather than reducing sales in one table alone.

For a customer concentration risk, explain collection monitoring, credit limits or steps to diversify revenue. For seasonal purchasing, show when inventory peaks and how funding will be arranged. Describe actions the business can realistically take, with management responsibility and timing where available.

Sensitivity analysis does not remove risk. It helps the borrower and bank understand the pressure points and whether additional contribution, a different repayment structure or a revised limit request needs discussion.

A final submission checklist

  1. Reconcile historical years with the signed or identified provisional records.
  2. Check sales, costs, holding levels and funding assumptions together.
  3. Confirm the working capital assessment method with the lender.
  4. Match repayments, interest, cash flow and closing debt balances.
  5. Review the complete exported report and supporting document index.

Finxora's CMA report software includes operating statements, balance sheet analysis, turnover and MPBF computations, cash flow, fund flow and sensitivity analysis. Those connected outputs can support preparation, but the source records and assumptions still require professional review. Compare the layout with the report samples and the bank's requested annexures before finalising the submission.

Frequently Asked Questions

Published on June 11, 2026

Updated on July 08, 2026

Back to Blog

Need bank-ready financials? Create a CMA report or a project report with Finxora in minutes.