What CMA ratio analysis means
CMA stands for Credit Monitoring Arrangement, the financial data pack Indian banks ask for before sanctioning working capital finance and during the annual review of an existing limit. The ratios in that pack are not an academic exercise. They are the credit team's shorthand for liquidity, leverage, activity and profitability, and each one carries a benchmark the bank compares against, along with the borrower's own history and the norms of the industry.
Ratio analysis is best read in three directions at once: against the benchmark, against the previous two or three years, and against the business model. A ratio that is weak but stable tells a different story from one that was comfortable last year and has slipped this year, and the second case is usually the one that prompts a question in the credit note.
Liquidity ratios
Liquidity ratios test whether the business can meet the obligations falling due within a year.
- Current ratio = current assets divided by current liabilities. Banks generally look for a comfortable margin above 1, and many credit teams want the figure nearer 1.33 for a working capital limit.
- Quick ratio = current assets minus inventory, divided by current liabilities. It removes stock, the slowest current asset to convert into cash.
- Cash ratio = cash and bank balances divided by current liabilities, the strictest of the three.
A current ratio that looks healthy only because finished goods are piling up is a warning rather than a comfort. Read it next to the stock holding period and the debtor collection period, because a ratio built on slow stock and old receivables is not real liquidity.
Leverage and solvency ratios
- Debt-equity ratio = total outside liabilities divided by net worth, or long-term debt divided by net worth, depending on the version the bank uses. A rising ratio shows growth is being funded with borrowed money.
- TOL/TNW = total outside liabilities divided by tangible net worth. Many banks set a ceiling in their credit policy, commonly around 3, and treat a breach as a reason to ask what changed.
- Interest coverage = earnings before interest and tax divided by interest. It shows how many times over the profit covers the interest bill.
Leverage is not automatically a fault. Borrowed money that funds an asset earning more than the interest cost adds to the return on equity. The difficulty arises when leverage sits on a business with thin margins or a slow cash conversion cycle, because the fixed interest has to be paid even in a poor month.
Activity ratios
Activity ratios measure how hard the assets work and how long cash stays locked in the operating cycle.
- Stock turnover = cost of goods sold divided by average inventory. Its inverse, multiplied by the days in the period, gives the stock holding period.
- Debtor collection period = average debtors divided by credit sales, multiplied by the days in the period.
- Creditor payment period = average creditors divided by credit purchases, multiplied by the days in the period.
These three periods form the operating cycle. When the cycle lengthens, the working capital gap widens and the limit the business can justify grows with it. A debtor period that jumps by thirty days can absorb more cash than a full year's profit, which is why the comparative statement matters as much as the ratio itself.
Profitability and debt service ratios
- Gross profit ratio and net profit ratio show the margin retained at each stage of the profit and loss account.
- Return on capital employed = earnings before interest and tax divided by capital employed, which tests whether the business earns more on its funds than the funds cost.
- DSCR = net profit plus depreciation plus term loan interest, divided by the principal and interest repayable in the year. A figure comfortably above 1 is the cushion a bank looks for, and the comfortable level varies with the sector.
Reading the ratios together
No single ratio decides a proposal. A high current ratio combined with a long debtor period can still leave a business short of cash. A low debt-equity ratio with a DSCR of barely 1 shows an under-leveraged business that nevertheless struggles to service what it has borrowed. Look for the story that links the four groups, and check the projections for the same discipline: growth in sales without a matching movement in debtors and stock is the most common flaw in a projected CMA file.
Trend matters as much as level. A current ratio of 1.2 that has improved from 1.0 over two years reads better than a static 1.4, because it shows the business is converting profit into liquidity. Note the direction of each ratio in the working papers, so the credit note does not have to reconstruct it.
Where ratio analysis meets MPBF
The ratios feed the working capital computation. Under the Tandon Committee approach, MPBF Method I is 75% × (total current assets − other current liabilities), and Method II is (75% × total current assets) − other current liabilities, with other current liabilities excluding bank borrowings. The borrower's margin is 25% of the working capital gap under the first method and 25% of total current assets under the second. Under the turnover method for MSMEs, the working capital requirement is taken as 25% of projected annual turnover, the borrower brings a margin of 5% of turnover, and bank finance can go up to 20% of turnover.
The current ratio and the holding levels decide which method gives the borrowing the business actually needs, so a ratio sheet that has been prepared carelessly shows up immediately in the limit calculation.
Common interpretation errors
- Comparing ratios across industries without allowing for the business model, since a trading firm and a manufacturer carry different norms.
- Reading a year-end balance sheet that has been dressed up for the occasion and ignoring the average position through the year.
- Using a ratio to judge the past while ignoring the assumptions behind the projected years.
- Overlooking off-balance-sheet items, statutory dues and contingent liabilities that reduce real net worth.
- Treating a single quarter's ratio as a trend when the business is seasonal.
Preparing the ratios without errors
Finxora's CMA report software computes 20+ financial ratios covering liquidity, profitability, leverage, activity, expense and growth, and measures each against bank benchmarks, so a change in one input recalculates the whole set. The operating statement, balance sheet, comparative statement, MPBF and ratio pages all read from the same figures, which removes the two-spreadsheet problem where the ratio sheet never quite agrees with the statements it came from.
A filled report is available in the samples library to compare with the format the bank shared, and the details of what each plan includes are on the CMA pricing page. Because the MPBF methods and the turnover method are computed from the same balance sheet, you can see which method binds before the file goes to the branch.
