A rejection is about the file, not the business
A bank turns down a loan application when the file, as presented, does not meet the parameters its credit team works with at that moment. The same proposal can be sanctioned a few months later with the same promoter and the same business, simply because the numbers, the security or the supporting documents changed. Reading a rejection that way is the first step to a better application.
What follows covers the reasons that come up most often for MSME and retail loans, what the bank is testing in each case, and the evidence that strengthens a fresh file.
What the credit team examines
Most appraisals move through five broad tests. Character is the repayment record and the conduct of the accounts. Capacity is the ability to service the loan from cash flow. Capital is the promoter's own contribution and net worth. Collateral is the security offered and how far it covers the exposure. Conditions cover the industry, the borrower category and the bank's own exposure limits. For a business loan the file also carries the current account turnover, income tax returns, GST returns, and the CMA data or project report that sets out the projections.
The usual reasons, and what strengthens the next file
| What the bank saw | What it signals | What strengthens a fresh file |
|---|---|---|
| Low credit score, past defaults, settled or written-off accounts, high card utilisation | Repayment behaviour has been weak | Clear the outstanding dues, dispute genuine errors in the credit report, bring utilisation down, and let the score improve before applying again |
| Thin or unstable income; for a business, weak and unsupported projections | Cash flow may not cover the instalment | Show two to three years of verified turnover, and base the projections on capacity, price and utilisation that you can defend |
| Existing obligations are large against income, or the debt-to-income ratio is high | The borrower is already stretched | Repay or consolidate small loans, close unused limits, and bring the total outside liabilities to net worth into a range the bank accepts |
| Incomplete documents, or a balance sheet that does not agree with the returns | The figures cannot be relied on | Submit a complete pack with statements that agree across the balance sheet, profit and loss account, GST returns and income tax returns |
| No financial projections, no CMA data or project report | The bank cannot see repayment capacity | Prepare CMA data for a working capital limit and a project report for a term loan, with DSCR, break-even and ratios worked out |
| Security shortfall, or a valuer's figure below the estimate | The bank is not fully covered | Offer unencumbered assets, add a co-applicant or guarantor where the bank allows it, and obtain a valuation from an approved valuer |
| A very new business with no track record | There is no history to judge | Bring in domain experience, a firm order or offtake arrangement, a larger promoter contribution, and a scheme such as CGTMSE where it applies |
| Cheque bounces, unfiled GST or income tax returns, statutory dues, litigation | Compliance and conduct concerns | Clear the dues, file the pending returns, and explain any dispute with documents |
| The sector or ticket size is outside the bank's current policy | Policy, not the borrower | Ask the relationship manager about the current policy, then approach a bank that lends to your sector and size |
The two report packs that answer most questions
For a working capital limit, banks ask for CMA data, where CMA stands for Credit Monitoring Arrangement. The pack carries the operating statement, the analysis of the balance sheet, the comparative statement of current assets and current liabilities, fund flow and cash flow statements, ratio analysis and the computation of maximum permissible bank finance, or MPBF. The first method allows 75% of the working capital gap, that is, MPBF = 75% of (total current assets minus current liabilities other than bank borrowings), with the borrower funding 25% of the gap. The second method allows MPBF = (75% of total current assets) minus current liabilities other than bank borrowings, which leaves the borrower a margin of 25% of total current assets. Where the exposure is small, banks often use the turnover method, under which the working capital requirement is 25% of projected annual turnover, the borrower brings in 5% of turnover as margin, and bank finance can go up to 20% of turnover. The CMA report software page sets out the statements such a pack contains, and a sample is available to compare with your bank's format.
For a term loan, the bank reads a project report, also called a detailed project report. It sets out the project cost, the means of finance, the projected profit and loss account, balance sheet and cash flow, the depreciation schedule, the EMI repayment schedule for each loan, DSCR, break-even and ratio analysis. DSCR is receipts, meaning net profit plus depreciation plus term loan interest, divided by the repayments of principal and interest, worked out for each year. A DSCR above 1 is the floor, and banks usually look for headroom over it, because the projected year in which the ratio is tightest is the one they question most. The project report software page shows the sections it generates, and the samples page carries a finished report you can read before building your own.
Applying again without wasting the effort
- Ask the relationship manager or the branch for the reason in writing. Where the reason is an entry in the credit report, obtain the report and check it for errors.
- Approach one or two banks at a time. Each application can trigger a credit enquiry, and a cluster of enquiries in a short period does not read well.
- Keep one version of the truth: the turnover in the GST returns, the income tax returns, the bank statements and the CMA data should agree. Differences invite questions.
- Match the request to the need. A cash credit limit for a seasonal build-up of stock is assessed differently from a term loan for machinery, and the report pack differs too.
- Wait until the numbers have actually changed. Reapplying to the same bank with the same file usually produces the same answer.
A pre-application checklist
- A credit report for the proprietor, partners or directors, checked and corrected.
- The last three years of financial statements and income tax returns, with the balance sheet tallying.
- GST returns and a turnover reconciliation against the books.
- Twelve months of bank statements for the operating account.
- CMA data for a working capital request, or a project report for a term loan, with DSCR, break-even and ratios.
- Security documents and valuation, and details of any existing borrowing.
- A short note on the business, its customers and its repayment plan.
Loan policies, scheme rules and credit parameters differ across banks and change over time, so confirm the requirements with the bank before you file.
