Finxora Logo
Sign In
Free Tools for CMA Data: What They Can and Cannot Do
Back to Blog

Free Tools for CMA Data: What They Can and Cannot Do

FINXORA
6 min read
cma
financial analysis
data software
free software
efficiency

Free spreadsheets can carry a CMA file up to a point. Here is where they work, where they break down, and what to look for when you move to dedicated software.

Why free tools look attractive for CMA work

CMA stands for Credit Monitoring Arrangement, the financial pack Indian banks ask for before sanctioning working capital finance and at every annual review of a limit. The format is fixed, the statements are well known, and almost every finance team already owns a spreadsheet. When the question is how to prepare CMA data at low cost, a free spreadsheet is the first answer that comes to mind.

That instinct is reasonable. LibreOffice Calc and Google Sheets cost nothing to use, they handle formulas and charts, and a template in the bank's format can be built in an afternoon. The question worth asking is narrower: how far do free tools take you before the manual work of holding the statements together becomes the bigger cost.

What free spreadsheets do well

  • Simple, single-year files. A one-off CMA summary for a small borrower fits comfortably in a spreadsheet.
  • Formulas and validation. Both tools support formulas, data validation and conditional formatting, which reduce keying errors.
  • Pivot tables and charts. Turning a sheet of figures into a ratio view or a trend chart is straightforward.
  • Sharing. A file can be shared with a colleague or a client without extra software.
  • Familiarity. No training is needed, which matters when a file has to be prepared today.

For a proprietor with one small limit and one reporting year, a well-built spreadsheet is often enough, and there is no reason to move away from it.

Where free tools break down

The difficulty starts when the file grows. CMA data is a set of interlinked statements: the operating statement feeds the balance sheet, the balance sheet feeds the fund flow and the MPBF computation, and all of them feed the ratios. In a spreadsheet every link is a formula someone has to maintain by hand, and a change in one assumption can leave another sheet quietly out of date.

  • Both MPBF methods. The first method and the second method must be computed side by side from the same balance sheet, with the turnover method beside them, and each has its own margin. Hand-built sheets frequently carry only one method.
  • The ratio set. Liquidity, profitability, leverage, activity, expense and growth ratios, each measured against a benchmark, are tedious to maintain and easy to leave stale.
  • Multi-year carry-forward. Closing balances must move into the next year's opening figures across the balance sheet, depreciation and loan schedules.
  • Renewals. The second and third years repeat much of the first, and rebuilding the file each time is where the hours disappear.
  • Review and version control. Two copies of a file circulating with different figures is a common problem before submission.

The hours a spreadsheet does not show

Take an ordinary case: a trading firm with a cash credit limit, three audited years and two projected years. In a spreadsheet, the operating statement needs each year built from the previous one, the balance sheet needs its own set of formulae pointing back at the operating statement, the fund flow and cash flow need another, and the MPBF sheet needs the current assets and current liabilities of every year restated in the comparison format. Then the ratios are drawn from all of them. That is five sheets and several hundred formulae, all maintained by the same person.

Now change one assumption, say the debtor days the bank queried. In linked software the change flows through every statement. In a spreadsheet, the operating statement, balance sheet, fund flow, cash flow, MPBF and ratio sheets must each be revisited, and a single missed cell produces a report that contradicts itself. The review before submission, not the typing, becomes the largest part of the work.

Where dedicated software changes the work

Dedicated CMA software keeps the statements linked. You enter the figures once, set the assumptions, and the statements recalculate together, so the operating statement, balance sheet, fund flow, MPBF computation and ratios always agree. For a practising chartered accountant, a DSA or a finance team preparing files through the year, that removes a full round of checking on every submission.

Finxora's CMA report software works this way. It builds the operating statement, analysis of balance sheet, comparative statement of current assets and current liabilities, the MPBF computation under the first and second methods with the turnover method beside them, fund flow and cash flow statements, DSCR, sensitivity and break-even analyses, the depreciation chart, the EMI schedule and a ratio set covering liquidity, profitability, leverage, activity, expense and growth. Saved masters keep each borrower's yearly details, so a renewal updates the provisional and projected years rather than starting again, and every report exports as a formatted PDF, Excel workbook or Word document.

How to choose between the two

The decision is a matter of volume and of what a mistake costs.

  1. Occasional, small files. A spreadsheet is fine. Keep a clean template, protect the formula cells and check the totals before printing.
  2. Regular files, or files with a working capital limit. Look for software that computes both MPBF methods, carries balances forward across years and lets you reuse the previous year's figures.
  3. Files prepared by a team. Prefer a single saved master over circulating spreadsheets, so everyone works from the same figures.
  4. Check the format. Whatever you use, the output should follow the standard CMA format the bank's credit team already reads.

If a tool asks you to retype figures that the last year's file already holds, or cannot show the bank both MPBF methods, it is not saving the work it appears to save.

Trying a dedicated tool before committing

Before paying for anything, look at a finished report. The samples page carries a filled CMA report in the layout a bank expects, with the operating statement, balance sheet, MPBF computation and ratio tables shown as they print, which is a faster way to judge a format than a feature list. The CMA report software page describes what the software produces, and the plans for the module are set out at pricing, so you can compare a spreadsheet's real cost in hours with the alternative.

Frequently Asked Questions

Published on February 14, 2026

Updated on September 08, 2026

Back to Blog

Need bank-ready financials? Create a CMA report or a project report with Finxora in minutes.