Start with the assessment method your bank requires
A Credit Monitoring Arrangement (CMA) report brings together historical accounts, provisional figures and projections for a bank's credit assessment. Its working capital section should explain how the requested finance follows from the business's needs. Two familiar approaches are the turnover method associated with the Nayak Committee and Maximum Permissible Bank Finance (MPBF) under the Tandon Committee methods.
These approaches answer different questions. The turnover method starts from projected annual turnover. MPBF starts from assessed current assets and other current liabilities. Neither computation, by itself, establishes an entitlement to a loan. The bank determines the applicable approach and evaluates the borrower, supporting evidence and terms of finance.
Turnover method: the 25%, 5% and 20% relationship
Under the turnover approach commonly associated with Nayak Committee recommendations for eligible MSME assessments, total working capital requirement is taken at 25% of projected annual turnover. The borrower's contribution is 5% of turnover, leaving bank finance up to 20% of turnover. Ask the lender about applicability and its treatment of the borrower's actual circumstances.
- Working capital requirement: 25% x projected annual turnover.
- Borrower margin: 5% x projected annual turnover.
- Bank finance: up to 20% x projected annual turnover.
The margin is 5% of turnover, not 5% of the working capital requirement. Expressed against the assumed requirement, the same contribution represents 20% of that requirement. Keeping the denominator explicit prevents a common calculation error.
Worked turnover example
Assume projected annual turnover of Rs 400 lakh. The assessed working capital requirement is 25% x Rs 400 lakh = Rs 100 lakh. The borrower contribution is 5% x Rs 400 lakh = Rs 20 lakh. Bank finance under this computation is up to Rs 80 lakh, which is 20% of turnover.
The projected Rs 400 lakh must still be supported. Review recent sales, order visibility, capacity, purchases and collection terms. A higher turnover forecast increases the formula result, but an unsupported forecast weakens the proposal. The assessed figure also needs to be read alongside the bank's sanction conditions and its overall appraisal.
The turnover method is different from operating-cycle analysis
Operating-cycle analysis studies the time and funds tied up in stock, production and customer collections, taking account of supplier credit. It helps explain why the business needs working capital and whether projected balances are reasonable. It is not another name for the percentage-of-turnover calculation.
For example, a manufacturer may examine raw material, work-in-progress and finished goods holding periods separately. A trader may concentrate on stock holding and receivable collection days. The relevant cost or sales basis should be stated for each component. Multiplying daily sales by a number of days alone does not replace a complete assessment of costs, asset categories and spontaneous credit.
A seasonal borrower can have a modest year-end stock figure and a much larger peak requirement. Describe the peak and the timing rather than assuming an annual average captures every funding need.
MPBF begins with assessed current assets and liabilities
For the formulas below, Total Current Assets means the current asset amount accepted for the assessment. Other Current Liabilities means current liabilities excluding bank borrowings. The working capital gap equals Total Current Assets minus Other Current Liabilities. That gap is funded through the borrower's contribution and working capital bank finance.
Distinguish this gap from accounting net working capital, which uses total current liabilities, including relevant bank borrowing. Using the same label for both quantities can cause bank finance to be deducted twice. Keep the accounting balance sheet and the assessment schedule linked through a clear reconciliation.
MPBF Method I
MPBF Method I = 75% x (Total Current Assets - Other Current Liabilities). The borrower contributes 25% of the working capital gap. If assessed current assets are Rs 160 lakh and other current liabilities are Rs 40 lakh, the gap is Rs 120 lakh. Required borrower contribution under this method is Rs 30 lakh and MPBF is Rs 90 lakh.
MPBF Method II
MPBF Method II = 75% x Total Current Assets - Other Current Liabilities. The borrower contributes 25% of total current assets. With the same assets of Rs 160 lakh and other current liabilities of Rs 40 lakh, borrower contribution is Rs 40 lakh. MPBF is Rs 120 lakh minus Rs 40 lakh = Rs 80 lakh.
The placement of brackets matters. Method I applies 75% after deducting other current liabilities. Method II applies 75% to current assets first and then deducts those liabilities. Do not describe both methods as 75% of the working capital gap.
Compare the three results without mixing their bases
The following illustrative business has turnover of Rs 400 lakh, assessed current assets of Rs 160 lakh and other current liabilities of Rs 40 lakh. All amounts in the table are in lakh rupees.
| Assessment | Requirement or gap | Borrower contribution | Bank finance computation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turnover method | 100 | 20 | Up to 80 |
| MPBF Method I | 120 | 30 | 90 |
| MPBF Method II | 120 | 40 | 80 |
The matching Rs 80 lakh results in this example are coincidental. Changing stock or receivable assumptions can change MPBF without changing the turnover calculation. Conversely, changing turnover without revising projected asset balances can leave the schedules economically inconsistent. Review the full projection whenever an important assumption changes.
Do not automatically choose the largest figure or assume the lower of Methods I and II is always the prescribed sanction. Obtain the bank's assessment instructions and explain any difference between the calculated amount, the requested facility and the borrower's proposed contribution.
Checks that improve CMA accuracy
- Use the same year, currency unit and borrower across every schedule.
- Separate bank borrowings from other current liabilities in the MPBF working.
- Reconcile projected stock and debtors to holding periods and operating assumptions.
- Identify how the borrower contribution will be funded and retained in the business.
- Check interest, cash flow and closing borrowings against the requested facility.
- Explain changes in eligible asset treatment and differences from historical accounts.
Review overdue debtors, slow-moving inventory and non-operating current assets with the lender. Their accounting classification does not settle their eligibility for assessment. Likewise, a computed borrowing amount and drawing power against periodic stock and receivable statements are separate concepts; follow the facility's conditions when preparing either calculation.
For the related preparation guidance, see maximum permissible bank finance formulas.
Use software to organise the workings
Finxora's CMA report software provides turnover-method and MPBF computations alongside operating statements, balance sheet analysis, ratios, fund flow and cash flow. It calculates both MPBF methods from the report inputs and exports reports in PDF, Excel and Word. The preparer must still verify source figures, classification and the bank's assessment requirements.
Review the sample reports to understand the presentation before assembling a borrower file. A transparent report shows the formula, the inputs and the reason for the requested limit, allowing the lender to assess the proposal without reconstructing the calculation.
