The short answer: one document, two names
In a bank loan file, a detailed project report (DPR) and a project report describe the same appraisal document. The name changes with the file rather than the content: banks and MSME applications usually say project report, while term-loan and government scheme files often say DPR. The differences that matter are in scope, depth and who reads it, not in a wholly separate kind of paper.
What a project report contains
A project report is the document a bank studies before it sanctions credit. It introduces the promoter and the business, costs the project, shows how that cost will be funded, and projects how the unit will sell, earn and repay over the years the loan runs. Every rupee of project cost has to appear in the means of finance, and every year's profit has to flow into the projected balance sheet and the cash flow. A working capital proposal carries the same logic in the operating statement, the ratio analysis and the MPBF working.
What a DPR adds
A DPR is the fuller form of the same document. Where a small working-capital file may run to a few pages of projections and ratios, a term loan or a subsidy application is expected to explain the ground behind the numbers: the location and its demand, the plant and machinery, the implementation schedule, the promoter's contribution, and a year-by-year repayment plan. In practice the DPR is the version prepared when the ticket size, the scheme or the bank's appraisal desk calls for a detailed file.
Where the differences really sit
| Point | Project report | DPR |
|---|---|---|
| Common use | Working capital limits, small MSME loans, renewal files | Term loans, new units, government scheme applications |
| Depth | Project cost and funding, projections, key ratios | Same core plus market, technical and implementation detail |
| Reader | Branch credit officer | Credit desk, scheme committee or sanctioning authority |
| Length | Short and summary-led | Long, with schedules and explanations |
The statements both must get right
Whatever the name on the cover, the appraisal rests on the same few workings:
- Project cost and means of finance, with the two sides agreeing.
- Projected profit and loss account, balance sheet and cash flow for each year.
- Debt service coverage: DSCR is receipts (net profit plus depreciation plus term-loan interest) divided by repayments (principal plus interest) for each year.
- Ratio analysis: the current ratio, TOL/TNW, debt-equity, interest coverage and the return ratios a credit officer reads together.
- Working capital: the turnover method, where the requirement is 25 per cent of projected annual turnover with a 5 per cent margin and bank finance of up to 20 per cent, and MPBF under the Tandon Committee methods.
MPBF in one paragraph
MPBF, the maximum permissible bank finance, follows two common methods. Method I allows 75 per cent of (total current assets minus other current liabilities), which leaves the borrower a margin of 25 per cent of the working capital gap. Method II allows 75 per cent of total current assets minus other current liabilities, which raises the borrower's margin to 25 per cent of total current assets. Other current liabilities here means current liabilities excluding bank borrowings. Banks may apply either method, and some fall back on the turnover method for smaller limits.
Common mistakes in either document
Most rejections trace back to a handful of errors: a project cost that does not tie to the means of finance, projections that grow without any cost or capacity behind them, a DSCR that ignores the moratorium or the EMI start date, a balance sheet that does not tally, and ratios quoted without the formula or the year they belong to. A report assembled from one set of inputs avoids most of these, because the summary, the statements and the schedules are calculated from the same figures rather than typed separately.
Who prepares the file
A chartered accountant, a loan consultant or the promoter's own accounts team usually assembles the document. The figures come from the audited accounts for the past years and from the promoter's assumptions for the projected years, and the bank expects the two to be reconciled: the last audited year should flow into the first projected year without a jump. When several lenders, or a term loan and a working capital limit, are involved, each statement should say which facility it serves and where the repayment sits.
Which one should you prepare?
Start from what the bank has asked for. If the sanction letter, the scheme guideline or the credit officer's checklist names a DPR, prepare the fuller document; if it asks for a project report, the summary-led version is enough, and adding a market and technical section does no harm when the ticket size is large. When in doubt, prepare the fuller file, since a DPR contains everything a shorter project report does and the extra detail rarely counts against the proposal.
Format the bank expects
Indian banks work from a standard appraisal order, and it helps to follow it even when the bank does not spell it out: promoter and entity profile first, then the project cost and the means of finance, then the projected statements, the debt service working and the ratios, and finally the assumptions, schedules and any scheme forms. A cover page with the firm's details and a chartered accountant's block is usual when a professional signs the file. A report that follows this order reads quickly and, more usefully, it forces the writer to reconcile each year instead of leaving two versions of the same figure in the file.
Working capital file vs term loan file
The two cases differ more than the cover name suggests. A working capital file leans on history: the audited accounts, the current assets and current liabilities, the operating cycle, and the MPBF or turnover-method computation, with projections mainly to show that sales will support the higher limit. A term loan file leans on the future: the cost of the asset, the capacity it creates, the repayment schedule and the DSCR over the loan's life. Where the business is both borrowing for an asset and raising its limit, the bank will usually read the two sets of numbers in one document.
How software helps
Finxora's project report software treats the project report and the DPR as one bank document. You enter the project cost, the means of finance, the revenue and expense assumptions and the loan terms; the app builds the profit and loss account, projected balance sheet, cash flow, depreciation chart, a month-wise EMI schedule for each loan, DSCR, ratio analysis, break-even, and the turnover method and MPBF working. The finished report can be exported as PDF, Word, Excel or JSON with the sections you choose, and a sample project report shows the order before you start. Pricing for the module is on the project report plans page.
