Start with evidence behind the CMA report
Credit Monitoring Arrangement (CMA) data brings historical financial statements, provisional results and projections into a bank loan proposal. A report can balance mathematically while still presenting an unreliable picture of the borrower. Incorrect classifications, unsupported sales assumptions and stale receivables can distort the assessment without producing an obvious arithmetic error.
Evaluating CMA data therefore requires two separate questions: do the statements agree with their source records, and do the assumptions reflect the business? This review is relevant to cash credit renewals, limit enhancements and proposals that combine working capital with term finance. The bank's requested format and assessment requirements should guide the final pack.
Establish a reliable starting point
Create a source register before examining ratios. Identify the borrower, constitution, financial year, reporting date and unit of measurement for every document. Mixing rupees with lakhs or audited figures with an earlier provisional version can create differences that are difficult to trace once projections have been prepared.
- Collect signed financial statements and their supporting schedules for historical years.
- Obtain the current trial balance, provisional accounts and ledger details for material balances.
- Use stock records, receivable ageing, creditor ageing and loan statements to support classifications.
- Keep a separate schedule of existing facilities, outstanding balances and repayment obligations.
- Record who supplied each assumption and when it was last reviewed.
Label each year as audited, provisional, estimated or projected. A recently prepared spreadsheet does not turn an unaudited year into an audited one. Where a schedule is missing, record the limitation rather than treating the balance as verified.
Reconcile the statements before interpreting them
Historical sales, expenses, assets and liabilities should trace to the approved source accounts. Where CMA presentation differs from the published balance sheet, prepare a mapping schedule. This explains legitimate reclassifications and prevents a reviewer from confusing a presentation change with an accounting adjustment.
Check that opening balances agree with the preceding closing balances. Reconcile capital additions, drawings, retained earnings and debt movements. An increase in net worth should have an identifiable source; it should not appear only because the projected balance sheet required a balancing figure.
Compare reported borrowing with lender statements and the facility schedule. Sanctioned limits and actual outstanding balances serve different purposes and must not be substituted for each other. Interest expense should be plausible in relation to average utilisation, interest rates and the period covered, allowing for documented timing differences.
Read red flags as questions to investigate
| Observation | Possible explanation | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|
| Sales rise while collections weaken | Longer customer credit or delayed recovery | Ageing, receipts after year-end and credit terms |
| Inventory rises faster than activity | Seasonal buying, slow stock or valuation changes | Stock ageing, quantities and valuation workings |
| Profit improves but operating cash falls | More funds tied up in the operating cycle | Cash flow and working capital movement |
| Net worth increases without retained profit | Fresh capital or an unexplained adjustment | Capital account and funding evidence |
| Creditors shrink sharply in projections | Reduced supplier credit requiring replacement finance | Supplier terms and projected payment schedule |
None of these observations proves manipulation. A distributor may build stock before a selling season, and a manufacturer may extend credit to a new institutional customer. The concern is an unexplained movement or an explanation that conflicts with supporting records.
Examine current asset quality
Receivables need more than a closing total. Separate overdue, disputed and related-party amounts, review credit notes, and inspect subsequent receipts. An invoice appearing in the ledger is evidence of a recorded claim, not evidence that collection is certain. Keep any accounting adjustment distinct from the bank's eligibility treatment.
For inventory, review quantity records, valuation policy and obsolete or damaged stock. Separate raw materials, work in progress and finished goods where relevant. A change in valuation method can alter both profit and stock without improving cash generation. Explain such changes rather than presenting them as operating growth.
Advances, prepaid expenses and other current assets also need scrutiny. Classification as a current asset does not automatically make an item eligible for drawing power. Banks can apply exclusions, ageing limits and margins that differ from the accounting presentation.
Use ratios to locate inconsistencies
Compare the current ratio, profitability margins, holding periods and TOL/TNW across years. Recalculate selected ratios independently from the underlying statements. Confirm that the denominator and debt classifications remain consistent before interpreting a sudden improvement.
A stronger current ratio can coexist with poor liquidity if receivables are overdue or inventory cannot be sold. Similarly, a lower debt ratio may reflect capital introduced shortly before year-end rather than sustained cash generation. Read the ratios alongside cash flow, asset quality and the timing of transactions.
Avoid imposing one benchmark on every business. Trading, manufacturing and service businesses have different operating cycles. The lender's policy, sector, seasonality and borrower history determine which movements need further explanation.
Test whether projections connect to operations
Projected sales should connect to capacity, orders, customer demand or an explicit commercial assumption. Higher turnover generally changes purchases, inventory, receivables, creditors and interest. A projection that increases sales while freezing every working capital balance may understate the finance required.
Ask how each major assumption was formed. If collection days improve, identify the operational change supporting that improvement. If gross margin rises, examine product mix, selling prices and purchase costs. Where a new asset increases capacity, align commissioning, depreciation and financing with its expected start date.
Run a downside scenario with slower collections or lower sales. Check whether cash remains sufficient for expenses and repayments. The purpose is to expose funding pressure before submission, not to select assumptions solely because they produce a preferred ratio.
Maintain a review trail through submission
Keep an exception register showing the issue, source reference, explanation, correction and reviewer. Distinguish verified differences from unresolved questions. When the borrower supplies revised accounts, update every affected statement and remove superseded versions from the submission pack.
Finxora's CMA report software prepares linked statements, MPBF computations, cash flow and ratio analysis from entered figures. These calculations assist preparation; the preparer still needs to verify source records and assumptions. Review a sample report to understand the presentation, then compare the final output with the bank's checklist.
Before release, confirm the reporting periods, units, statement totals, debt schedule and unresolved qualifications. A credible CMA submission makes its evidence and assumptions traceable, giving the borrower and lender a clear basis for discussing the proposal.
