What the bank is really assessing
A CMA data file is not a formality. When a credit officer opens it, three questions run in the background. Can this business repay what it borrows? How much working capital finance can its operating cycle genuinely support? And is the projection in front of me credible, or built to fit the request? Better CMA data does not change the business, but it answers those questions clearly and removes the doubts that delay a sanction.
CMA stands for Credit Monitoring Arrangement. It is the standard pack Indian banks ask for with working capital facilities such as cash credit, overdraft and working capital demand loans, at sanction, at enhancement and at every annual renewal. It combines audited history with the current year's provisional figures and the projected years, all in interlinked statements.
What a complete CMA file contains
- Operating statement, showing sales, direct and indirect costs, interest, tax and net profit for each year.
- Analysis of balance sheet, showing capital, reserves, borrowings, current liabilities and current assets, year on year.
- Comparative statement of current assets and current liabilities, with changes and movement ratios.
- Computation of maximum permissible bank finance under the two methods.
- Fund flow statement and cash flow statement.
- DSCR analysis for debt servicing comfort.
- Turnover method computation alongside the MPBF working.
- Ratio analysis covering liquidity, profitability, leverage, activity, expense and growth.
- Sensitivity and break-even analysis for the projected years.
- Depreciation schedule and EMI schedule for term loans attached to the borrower.
MPBF: the number the file has to get right
The maximum permissible bank finance decides the limit, so it deserves the most care. Under the first method, MPBF is 75 per cent of the working capital gap, that is, 75% × (total current assets − other current liabilities). Under the second method it is (75% × total current assets) − other current liabilities. In both formulas, other current liabilities means current liabilities excluding bank borrowings. The difference between the two is the margin the borrower has to bring in: 25 per cent of the working capital gap under the first method, and 25 per cent of total current assets under the second.
Banks also use the turnover method, based on the Nayak Committee recommendation for MSMEs. It sets the working capital requirement at 25 per cent of projected annual turnover, with the borrower contributing 5 per cent of turnover as margin and the bank financing up to 20 per cent. Where the two approaches differ, the lower figure usually binds, and the file should show both so the request is defensible.
Ratios the credit team reads first
Ratios are calculated from the statements, not typed in, and a good file presents them year on year with the movement explained.
- Liquidity: current ratio and quick ratio, which show whether short-term assets cover short-term dues.
- Leverage: debt-equity, total outside liabilities to net worth, total term liabilities to net worth, and interest coverage.
- Debt servicing: DSCR for every projected year, with the average the bank looks at.
- Activity: stock turnover and debtor turnover, which justify the holding levels behind the projections.
- Profitability: gross profit ratio, net profit ratio and return on capital employed.
Finxora's CMA report software calculates 20+ financial ratios from the same figures, measured against bank benchmarks, so nothing on the ratio page contradicts the statements behind it.
Five habits that make a CMA file credible
- Match the history to the audited accounts. Opening balances, depreciation and reserves should tie to the audited balance sheet and the income tax return. A mismatch here costs the file its credibility at the first review.
- Tie projections to capacity and holding levels. Sales growth needs capacity, utilisation and realisation behind it. A sales figure that grows faster than the plant is the quickest way to invite a query.
- Keep the provisional year realistic. The provisional figures should sit consistently with GST turnover, bank statements and the order book.
- Write the assumptions down. Sales growth, margins and the working capital cycle should each be stated, and the same assumptions should run through all the statements.
- Compare with the earlier file. At renewal, the bank looks for movement between years, and comparative statements with the change shown make the story easy to follow.
Where CMA files usually lose time
- MPBF that does not agree with the balance sheet figures it is drawn from.
- A projected current ratio that improves without any change in the working capital cycle.
- Term loan repayment shown in one place and a different instalment in the DSCR working.
- Depreciation that differs between the operating statement and the fixed asset schedule.
- Figures that do not match the project report or the income tax return filed for the same years.
Each of these is an avoidable query. A file where the statements agree with one another moves faster, because the credit officer can spend the time on the proposal instead of on reconciliation.
Better data is not the same as a promise of sanction
No document decides a credit decision on its own. The bank weighs the business, the industry, the promoter's record and its own policy along with the file. What good CMA data does is remove the errors and gaps that make a sound proposal look weak, and let the assessment rest on the business rather than on the paperwork. Requirements and formats vary from bank to bank, so it is worth checking the relationship manager's expectations before the file is submitted.
Preparing the file in software
In Finxora's CMA report software, you enter the borrower's figures once and the app builds the operating statement, balance sheet analysis, comparative statement, MPBF computation under both methods, fund flow, cash flow, DSCR, turnover method, ratio analysis, depreciation and EMI schedules from those inputs. Change an assumption and every statement recalculates together, so the MPBF cannot drift away from the balance sheet. The borrower's master stays saved, which means a renewal updates the provisional and projected years instead of rebuilding the file.
Open the sample CMA report to see the format these statements print in, then check the CMA plans when you are ready to prepare your own file.
