What a working capital assessment decides
When a business asks for a cash credit, overdraft or working capital demand loan, the bank has to answer a simple question: how much short-term finance does this operating cycle support? The assessment that answers it is prepared in the CMA format. CMA stands for Credit Monitoring Arrangement, and the pack is the standard way Indian banks read a borrower's history, provisional figures and projections before sanctioning a limit and at each annual renewal.
Indian Bank, like other banks, applies its own internal norms to the assessment, so the exact threshold, the security required and the margin can differ from one lender to another. The format, however, follows the same framework across the banking system, and that framework is what this guide sets out.
The components the bank examines
Current assets
- Cash and bank balances, including the balance in the borrowing account.
- Trade receivables, considered after the holding level the bank is prepared to accept, and usually supported by an ageing statement.
- Inventory in raw material, work in progress, finished goods, stores and consumables, each considered against a holding norm.
- Loans and advances that will convert to cash within the year, and prepaid expenses.
- Other current assets, such as claims receivable and deposits maturing within the year.
Current liabilities other than bank borrowings
- Trade payables and outstanding expenses.
- Advances received from customers.
- Statutory dues such as GST and TDS payable.
- Other current liabilities and the current maturities of long-term debt.
Borrowings from banks and financial institutions are kept out of this list on purpose. The assessment works out how much the borrower's own cycle needs, and then decides how much of it the bank will fund.
Working capital gap and margin
The working capital gap is the total of current assets less current liabilities other than bank borrowings. Part of that gap must be funded by the borrower as margin, and part may be funded by the bank. How the split is fixed depends on the method the bank applies.
The three methods of assessment
MPBF, first method
The maximum permissible bank finance is 75 per cent of the working capital gap, that is, 75 per cent of (total current assets less current liabilities other than bank borrowings). The borrower brings in the remaining 25 per cent of the gap as margin. The Tandon Committee said the first method gives a minimum current ratio of 1:1 (1.17:1 in its own illustration) and the second method a current ratio of at least 1.3:1 (1.33:1 in the illustration), and RBI has since withdrawn the mandatory MPBF prescription; the version a bank applies should be confirmed with the relationship manager.
MPBF, second method
The maximum permissible bank finance is 75 per cent of total current assets, less current liabilities other than bank borrowings. The borrower's margin works out to 25 per cent of total current assets. Because the margin is measured against the assets rather than the gap, this method usually produces a lower limit than the first.
Turnover method
For micro, small and medium enterprises the turnover method, following the Nayak Committee, is often used. The working capital requirement is taken as 25 per cent of the projected annual turnover. The borrower provides a margin of 5 per cent of turnover, and bank finance is available up to 20 per cent of turnover. Banks commonly ask for a CMA statement even when the turnover method fixes the limit, because the projections and the ratio analysis still have to be tested.
What the CMA format contains
- Operating statement for the past, current and projected years.
- Analysis of the balance sheet, year on year.
- Comparative statement of current assets and current liabilities, showing the holding levels in days and the movement ratios.
- Computation of maximum permissible bank finance under the first and second methods.
- Turnover method computation where it applies.
- Fund flow and cash flow statements.
- DSCR analysis and the ratio analysis covering liquidity, leverage, profitability and activity.
- Depreciation schedule and the EMI schedule for term loans.
Documents usually asked for
- Audited financial statements for the last two or three years, with the income tax returns.
- Provisional statements for the current year.
- Stock and debtor statements, usually monthly, once the limit is running.
- Details of the existing borrowing and the security offered.
- Registration papers, GST returns and the promoter's KYC.
The operating cycle and holding levels
Beneath the statement format sits the operating cycle: the time taken to buy raw material, convert it into finished goods, sell them and collect the money. A cycle of 90 days means the business must fund roughly three months of cost at any point, and that funding is what the limit covers. Banks express the cycle through holding levels, quoting stock and debtors in days of the relevant turnover or cost figure. A raw material holding of 30 days, a finished goods holding of 20 days and a debtor collection period of 45 days add up to a cycle that can be measured against the norm for the industry, and the comparative statement in the CMA format shows the same figures for each year so the movement is visible.
How the limit is reviewed each year
A working capital limit is not a permanent figure. It is reviewed annually, when the bank looks at the audited accounts, the latest stock and debtor statements and any request for enhancement. The review is also the point at which the borrower can present a stronger case, usually by showing a shorter collection cycle or a higher turnover within the same limit. Building the renewal on the previous year's file rather than from scratch keeps the comparisons consistent.
Preparing the assessment without a rebuild every year
Most of the effort is in keeping the statements consistent. The projections have to flow from the same assumptions into the operating statement, the balance sheet, the fund flow and the MPBF computation, and the renewal has to carry forward what was agreed last year.
Finxora's CMA report software builds the whole pack from one set of inputs, computes the maximum permissible bank finance under both methods with the turnover method beside them, and calculates the ratios from the statements rather than from a separate sheet. The report exports as a formatted PDF for submission, or as an Excel workbook or Word document. A filled sample CMA report shows how the comparative statement, the holding levels and the MPBF pages print, and the CMA plans set out what each plan covers.
